Conversation

🌸 lumi-nhac catbite no_ai antifa 🌱

remember kids, it’s not ok to wish death to other people

but companies aren’t people. feel free to wish for their demise

4
1
0

@lumi i like wishing death on people

1
0
0

@lumi what about wishing life on people?

1
0
1

@elexia sure. you can also wish wife on people

1
1
0

@elexia i wish many wife on u

1
0
0

also, i’m serious, do not send death threats or wish harm onto people. that’s really not the way we should be going

3
0
0

@lumi People I respect saying things like this are important to me. I need to hear it because I'm trying to become more human again

1
0
1

@lumi Wrong, we wish death on bad people and don't on good people.

1
0
0

@sackofbones i wish them to stop doing bad things, which means removing them from the environment where they can do so; which means removing their power

2
0
0

@sackofbones i know i may sound very naive, and i realize things likely can’t go in that way, but it is still my ideal

0
0
0

@lumi Sometimes to stop bad things you need to remove the ability for the people that do them to do them. I'm sure you wouldn't have objected to hanging hitler or himmler or eichman or stalin, I agree with you for most people but there are some that we can't help.

1
0
1

@sackofbones well, sometimes violence may need to be enacted to stop someone from enacting violence, which is unfortunate

in extreme cases, like hitler and such, i’m not going to object to hanging them. of course not

i want to be a hard-line anarcho-pacifist, but i know that’s not going to work out in the real world neocat_pensive

1
0
0
@lumi @sackofbones I would object to hanging them. human rights apply to everyone without exception, and should only be violated to the minimum amount necessary (imprisonment can be justified, killing except in self-defense (in a situation where there isn't another alternative) cannot be). anything beyond this is retribution (aka revenge), and cannot be morally justified, no matter how tempting it may be. the death penalty is completely unjustifiable in all cases, you can just imprison them for life. the right to life is absolute.

having said that, I do sometimes wish death on people and want revenge on people who have wronged me. I know it's wrong, but it's an emotional reaction that I can't control
2
0
2

@noisytoot @sackofbones yeah, you’re right. i want a better world, not revenge

0
0
1

@noisytoot I don't actually believe in human rights. I believe in rights inherent to being sentient and given that we are moral actors we are obliged to respect them.

> human rights apply to everyone without exception
Okay sure, I'll hold you to that if that's what you want to believe.

> imprisonment can be justified
How is that justifiable if human rights apply to everyone without exception? Article 13 of the universal declaration of human rights forbids it.

> killing except in self-defense
Firstly that's what hanging them would be, or would you rather it be specifically some Jewish person or someone from during the Holodomor that did it? It's possible to defend other people as self defense, we have a duty to protect those that cannot protect themselves.

> anything beyond this is retribution (aka revenge)
Revenge is a perfectly fine thing to want. Revenge is moral.

> and cannot be morally justified
Why?

> the death penalty is completely unjustifiable in all cases
Why? So you object to Nuremberg? You seriously believe that nazi scum is worthy of life?

> you can just imprison them for life.
Article 13 of the universal declaration of human rights forbids it.

> the right to life is absolute.
You a vegan by any chance?

1
0
0

@sackofbones

imprisonment can be justified

How is that justifiable if human rights apply to everyone without exception? Article 13 of the universal declaration of human rights forbids it.

Perhaps “without exception” wasn’t the correct phrasing. Sometimes violating those rights is unfortunately necessary in order to defend the rights of others, but those violations should be minimized as much as possible. I think killing someone is a more severe violation of their rights than simply limiting their freedom of movement, and that the latter can be justified by necessity but the former cannot (except self-defense where you or someone else is in immediate danger, but see the next paragraph for more about that).

killing except in self-defense

Firstly that’s what hanging them would be, or would you rather it be specifically some Jewish person or someone from during the Holodomor that did it? It’s possible to defend other people as self defense, we have a duty to protect those that cannot protect themselves.

You missed the “(in a situation where there isn’t another alternative)” part. In any situation where you would consider hanging someone, you can almost certainly imprison them instead, which would have the same effect, but would be a lesser violation of their rights. The kind of situation where killing could be justified in self-defense is one where you (or someone else) is in immediate danger (for example you’re being threatened with a gun), but never one where you’ve already captured and tried the person who is a danger.

anything beyond this is retribution (aka revenge)

Revenge is a perfectly fine thing to want. Revenge is moral.

and cannot be morally justified

Why?

The goal of any system of justice should be to defend the rights of everyone, by preventing people from doing things that harm others, while also minimizing the harm done to perpetrators (that is, criminals still have rights, no matter how bad the thing they’ve done is, and they can only be violated to the minimum extent necessary to protect others). Revenge is not conducive to this goal.

the death penalty is completely unjustifiable in all cases

Why? So you object to Nuremberg? You seriously believe that nazi scum is worthy of life?

I object to the death penalty. I do not object to trying nazis, but I would rather they be imprisoned for life instead. (And it could also be argued that killing them is actually giving them an easy way out, for example Hitler chose to kill himself rather than be captured and tried, and there have been other war criminals who have done similar things)

you can just imprison them for life.

Article 13 of the universal declaration of human rights forbids it.

Article 3 forbids killing them

the right to life is absolute.

You a vegan by any chance?

vegetarian

1
0
0

@noisytoot Yeah no I don't want to debate someone on if nazis deserve life, they don't, I would kill every nazi alive if I had the chance. If you support or commit genocide you forfeit your right to life, that simple. Same with any "universal" right, if you commit an egregious enough violation of others' rights then you forfeit it.

And this may be a shocker to you but I don't believe in your system of justice shit, I believe that we have the right to retribution for what has been done to us. The slaves had the right to kill the slavers. The Ukrainians had the right to kill the USSR's politicians for the Holodomor. The native americans had the right to kill the colonizers.

I take it from your pfp that you're trans also, yet you refuse to support getting justice for what we've been through. We've been targeted and murdered and had genocide enacted upon us for a good part of recorded history, it's about time we dole out some of what was done to us. Get blocked, I don't interact with nazi sympathizers

1
0
0
entirely pointless reply since you blocked me
Show content
@sackofbones I don't believe that it is possible to forfeit the right to life, and supporting the universal right to life does not in any way make me a nazi sympathizer.
0
0
0