Is it ok for straight people to eavesdrop on Pride Discourse?
#EvanPoll #poll #PrideDiscourse #HappyPride
@evan even straight people want to hear the tea from the other side sometimes ;)
@evan eavesdropping is a curious term to use in relation to public discourse, or do you mean to imply more private conversations?
@evan [Yes] Unless I'm missing something, just as it's okay for straight people to, e.g. read queer literature, no?
@emc2 I don't usually provide detailed definitions here:
https://evanp.me/pollfaq#define
So, please answer as you'd like!
@evan I'm unsure by the meaning of the capital letter in Discourse. To me that implies a specific instance of discourse that is commonly referred to as Pride Discourse as a proper noun.
But I'm struggling to imagine a quasi-official instance of discourse (either plain English meaning or the discussion software product meaning).
If you just mean 'read public discussions by people who participate in Pride activities in any of many public discussion fora', then would think it's ok, generally.
@evan sometimes straight people are just people who haven't found their way yet
in my experience in trans spaces over the last idk something like 18 years, the majority of well meaning cis people who wander in to be better allies etc and stick around usually turn out to not have been cisgender. so like even from the mindset of "this is a private safe space" it still makes sense to be at least a little welcoming because you don't know who is in the closet.
@evan I just clicked "see results" rather than voting, so I could eavesdrop on the discourse about eavesdropping on the discourse
@virtuous_sloth @evan also having trouble answering because I don't know if it's "Pride Discourse" or "Pride discourse".
@stinerman @virtuous_sloth it is an ill-advised attempt at humour, jokingly suggesting that Pride Discourse is a shared community institution with its own capitalized title. I've lowercased it, which I hope helps you answer the question.
@evan @virtuous_sloth sorry for being a little thick. I figured that might be the case, but I erred on the side of caution.
@stinerman @virtuous_sloth it's ok. I should say what I mean.
@evan @stinerman As I was composing my first reply, I had also thought to ask, in a similarly joking way, "Wait, there's an Official Pride Discourse®?" but but was reluctant at the possibility that you were not joking and I shit on something serious. Thus the sincere confusion reply.
🌳
@evan I would love to listen and learn, but will leave any conversation I'm not welcome in.
@evan Yes 100% - Doing this I think genuinely improved my empathy towards LGBTQI community.
@evan Eavesdropping implies unobtrusive listening, and it seems like a way to learn or gain understanding without intruding. So, like that, yeah! Also, nosying into private whispers is definitely not cool. Use your judgment.
Is it okay for straight people to vote on "Is it ok for straight people to eavesdrop on Pride discourse?"?
@evan I'm going to say 'no' just because eavesdropping itself is kind of icky.
@evan
Silly question. Pride discourse on this platform is entirely unavoidable, not that I would try to avoid it.
No one is "eavesdropping" we're just here.
@evan Yes, in public. Listening is a great way to learn. And sometimes we're loud.
@roknrol yeah, but isn't that most of public social media?
@gam3 But who's allowed to vote in this one??? We might have an infinite recursion problem.
@evan That's more like listening to the person on the corner that's shouting, I think.
@roknrol or listening to the people at the next table at a restaurant.
@evan If they're shouting or at least talking really really loudly? Sure, maybe. If the conversation is not meant for the general public, I generally try to avoid listening in.
@gam3 @evan Is it okay for straight people to vote on:
(This is two polls in one to avoid infinite recursion)
@evan Lol, didn't know it was meant to be a secret 😁
I mean... this is pride we're talking about, I thought the point was to be seen and heard and reminded that queer folk are everywhere and not going anywhere?
i don't think the issue is hearing something. whatever we hear we hear
i think the crucial issue on this topic is us opening our big fat fucking mouths
when to speak, and when to shut the fuck up, is a very underrated skill in life
@evan I voted Yes since I learn more when I open my ears and keep my mouth shut.
Hey, everyone. Thanks for the responses. I think that this kind of listening-in on public discussions in communities that you're not necessarily a part of is a normal experience on social networks. It's a great way to learn about others in the world. I think it breaks down when you mistakenly assume that your opinion is solicited or welcome, or when you mistakenly assume that the ideas posted in public discourse are proportionally representative of the community as a whole.
Personally, I think it's kind of awesome that Pride is a shared resource that matters so much to so many different kinds of people, and I like that it's a subject of conversation and debate. Seeing the first bits of Pride discourse come across the wire is a harbinger of the season, like first hearing "The Little Drummer Boy" on the loudspeaker in Target in late October.
Oh, and: a few people in the replies thought "eavesdropping" was a strong term to use here. I don't consider it that bad; I think of it meaning overhearing people speaking in public. But "listening in" or "overhearing" might be a less charged term.
@evan yeah, the “is it ok” and “eavesdrop” made it sound somewhat surreptitious 😅
@evan personally I recommend that the straights just become pansexual, problem solved
@evan There are lots of cases where I listen in on, but stay out of, discourse involving communities I'm not directly a part of.
I do this because I want to learn about people and community dynamics. Understanding fault lines in other communities is a way to understand my own communities as well. Seeing the ways that people effectively resolve conflicts or differences - or don't - from a distance is a way of preparing for times when I'm in the middle of it.
But I stay out because I know I have neither the full context nor anything at stake. I do my best not to judge these communities based on the conflicts they have, because every community has some level of this, and internal discussion reflects things that communities need to work on that are not necessarily ready (if they ever will be) for how they engage with outsiders.
I try to approach these sorts of things as a student, not a spectator or a tourist.
@evan similarly, I sometimes spend significant amounts of time learning about crash outs, "falls from grace", etc. that people have had, not out of a purient interest, but because I want to be able to identify and correct if I ever find myself going even slightly down a path that could end up in a similar place
@evan This is simultaneously a really funny and kind of beautiful way to view it, to me. I feel changed.
@cwebber you're really cutting the Gordian knot there
@evan Like I read this and immediately imagined the "PRESIDENTIAL ALERT: THE GIRLS ARE FIGHTINGGGGG" meme but with jingle bells playing.
@evan it’s ridiculous to think they have the authority even as a premise. It’s a riot and they were never invited.