Conversation

Discord: We know our block feature is practically useless and others you share space with can easily know if they’re blocked, so let’s offer you an alternative that’s still useless, but just barely less so, called “ignore”

3
0
0

I don’t think I know anyone who would prefer a block where you are made fully aware that the user exists over a block where you don’t see or hear a thing about or from them.

Functionally useless.

2
0
0

Ignore - The other user can still react to what you say, send you DMs, and view your profile, but at least it’s not obvious that you have the feature enabled for them! 🤡

2
0
0

This could be an older feature at this point. I’m only just learning about it. I can’t stand to use the platform much these days.

0
0
0
@maddy Do you mean you prefer the Mastodon-style gaslight-block where it shows an empty profile and I am forever paranoid whether it's a technical issue or a block?
1
0
0

@LunaDragofelis I usually check profiles in a private window to verify (assuming the instance allows viewing a profile without being logged in/authorized fetch), but what I prefer is that at the very least, I don’t ever see anything out of the user I’ve blocked - I shouldn’t know they exist. Ideally, my posts should be private to the person I’m blocking, like how Sharkey does it.

I’m indifferent to the “this profile doesn’t exist” way of it being done, but I can see how it would bother some.

0
0
0

@maddy godddd i feel this

blocking or ignoring does me no good if i can still see the damn message and the user

0
0
0
@maddy out of curiosity, what would a *good* block feature be?
1
0
0

@yukijoou At the very least that I don’t ever see anything out of the user I’m blocking. If they’re tagged in a public comment or post, that’s whatever, but I don’t want to see boosts of the user’s posts, replies to said user’s posts - ever. I don’t want to know they exist if it’s to the point that I’m blocking them. My posts should be private to them as well (at least while they’re logged in to their account on their instance).

0
0
0
@maddy what's the problem with discord's block feature? (I have never used discord). do you mean that you can still see their reactions/DMs or just that they can send them into the void? the former would be a problem but the latter (along with them being able to view your profile) seems entirely expected, otherwise it'd be trivially detectable by them (also that is how I expect ignore to work, it's how it works on irc (which does not generally have a server-side block feature, just client-side ignores/filters)))
0
0
0